Ford Government Commits Up to $285M to TC Energy's Georgian Bay Pumped-Storage Project Despite Grid Operator's Warning
TL;DR
In an August 2021 memo obtained by The Narwhal, Ontario's grid operator warned that TC Energy's Meaford pumped-storage project was not expected to meet the province's short- or medium-term needs and belonged in a competitive procurement. In January 2025 the Ford government committed up to $285 million of public money to the company's pre-development work anyway.
Key: People Related scandals
The web
1 personWhy it matters
The province's own grid operator looked at TC Energy's Meaford proposal early and was wary. In an August 2021 memo obtained through freedom of information, The Narwhal reports, the Independent Electricity System Operator told the government that, given the project's long development timeline, it "is not expected to contribute to meeting Ontario's short- or medium-term system needs." The operator said the value of "long-lived capital intensive projects" like this one should be weighed in a competitive procurement, against other projects of similar scale, rather than through the unsolicited-proposal track TC Energy was using.
The memo also flagged significant risks, including "cost overruns and delays" and the need for "significant permitting and approvals" from both levels of government. The details of those risks are redacted. According to The Narwhal, most of the project would be built on Department of National Defence lands near Meaford, and the work requires major construction on the protected Niagara Escarpment and a water pipeline in Georgian Bay.
In January 2024, then-energy minister Todd Smith delayed his response to the operator and urged TC Energy to seek federal funding to mitigate its cost projections, The Narwhal reports. A year later the government committed the money anyway. On January 24, 2025, Energy Minister Stephen Lecce announced in a provincial news release that Ontario is "investing up to $285 million" to advance pre-development work, including "a detailed cost estimate and environmental assessments to determine the feasibility of the proposed project." The release says the province "will make a final decision on the project once a detailed cost estimate is complete."
That money carries the risk the operator described. An IESO spokesperson told The Narwhal the operator has a contract "that enables Trans Canada Energy to recover eligible, prudently incurred expenses" for the pre-development work, which has included drilling into the lakebed for environmental studies. The Ontario Ministry of Energy did not respond to The Narwhal's questions, as has been the case since June 2024, the outlet reports.
Rippling effects
The province has framed the project as part of an "all-of-the-above" response to rising electricity demand. The government's release says the facility would provide up to 1,000 megawatts of storage, and that TC Energy is proposing it in partnership with the Saugeen Ojibway Nation, which would have the opportunity to take an equity stake if the project is built. The release also says the project "can only proceed" following the pre-development work and approval of Bruce Power's expansion plans.
TC Energy says the spending is meant to settle the cost question. Spokesperson Sara Beasley told The Narwhal the investment would help the company "provide a more accurate estimate of the cost of the project," and that it "will need to demonstrate that it is cost-effective and is in the best interest of Ontarians before it moves forward." The province has committed up to $285 million toward finding that out.
The project is still years from a decision. According to the Municipality of Meaford, it is targeting a final investment decision in 2028 and an in-service date in the mid-2030s, and the federal Impact Assessment Agency of Canada has begun an impact assessment. In July 2026 Meaford council authorized a separate pre-development agreement with TC Energy that could provide the municipality and community groups up to $1.355 million a year, the municipality says.
