Skip to content
Independent · Sourced

Cabinet Riding Associations Spending Donor Cash

TL;DR

A Toronto Star analysis of Elections Ontario filings found five Ontario cabinet ministers' riding associations spent a combined $356,312 on "meetings hosted" across 2024 and 2025, at venues including a sashimi restaurant, a tequila bar and an axe-throwing establishment. The money came from donations that qualify for provincial tax credits.

Who benefited

  • Stephen Lecce · $79,647 over two years

    His riding association spent $79,647 across 2024 and 2025 in the "meetings hosted" category, second only to Michael Tibollo's. The King—Vaughan association's 2024 annual report shows $14,949 paid to Beretta Farms for a "community barbecue" at a King City farm. The Star contacted Lecce's office with specific questions 13 days before publication; his office did not respond.

  • Stan Cho · $68,646 over two years

    The former tourism minister's riding association spent a combined $68,646 across 2024 and 2025 in the "meetings hosted" category, in the Toronto Star's review of Elections Ontario filings by cabinet ministers' associations. The records do not reveal who attended the meetings or who, if anyone, benefited.

  • David Piccini · $57,325 over two years

    The Labour Minister's riding association spent a combined $57,325 across 2024 and 2025 in the "meetings hosted" category. The money came from political donations that qualify for provincial tax credits, alongside the public subsidy paid for each vote received.

  • Michael Kerzner · $40,472 over two years

    The Solicitor General's riding association spent a combined $40,472 across 2024 and 2025 in the "meetings hosted" category — one of the five cabinet ministers' associations whose two-year spending in that category totalled $356,312 in the Toronto Star's review.

  • Venu Event Space · $47,200 per year (2024, 2025)

    The Vaughan—Woodbridge PC riding association, represented by associate solicitor general Michael Tibollo, paid Venu Event Space $47,200 in each of the last two years for Tibollo's annual "Chestnut Roast" fundraiser, according to a Toronto Star analysis of riding association annual reports filed with Elections Ontario. That made it the top line item among the cabinet ministers' associations the Star reviewed. The money came from political donations that qualify for provincial tax credits and from the public subsidy paid for each vote received. Venu Event Space sold a venue and event services; the accountability question raised by the reporting is about how the riding association spent tax-subsidized money, not about the vendor.

  • Beretta Farms · $14,949 (2024)

    Energy Minister Stephen Lecce's King—Vaughan PC riding association reported paying Beretta Farms $14,949 in its 2024 Elections Ontario filing for a "community barbecue" at a King City farm, per a Toronto Star analysis of riding association annual reports. PC Party communications director Peter Turkington described it as a well-attended barbecue using "100% Canadian meat" from "a proudly King company," and said context was necessary. Lecce's office did not respond to questions the Star sent 13 days before publication. Beretta Farms supplied food; the accountability question raised by the reporting is about the riding association's use of donations that qualify for provincial tax credits, not about the supplier.

Connections graph

Key: People Related scandals

The web

9 people
Show 3 more

Why it matters

The Toronto Star's analysis of riding association annual reports filed with Elections Ontario for 2024 and 2025 found five cabinet ministers' associations that spent a combined $356,312 in the "meetings hosted" category over the two years. The settings included a city restaurant serving Japanese sashimi, a tequila bar, and an axe-throwing establishment.

The top spender was Vaughan-Woodbridge, represented by associate solicitor general Michael Tibollo, whose association paid Venu Event Space $47,200 in each of the last two years — $94,400 in total — for Tibollo's annual "Chestnut Roast" fundraiser, which invited politicians, police brass and community members. Combined two-year totals for the others: Stephen Lecce $79,647, former tourism minister Stan Cho $68,646, Labour Minister David Piccini $57,325, and Solicitor General Michael Kerzner $40,472. Lecce's King-Vaughan association's 2024 report shows $14,949 paid to Beretta Farms for a "community barbecue" at a King City farm.

This is not purely private money. The expenses were paid from political donations that qualify for provincial tax credits, alongside public subsidies parties receive for each vote won. The filings also do not reveal who attended these meetings or who, if anyone, benefited — which is what makes the category resistant to scrutiny.

The Star contacted Lecce's office 13 days before publication with specific questions; his office did not respond. PC Party communications director Peter Turkington said the Star had not provided a proper explanation, and described the King-Vaughan event as a "community barbeque, with hamburgers, snacks, and fun for the kids, hosting hundreds of residents, and local stakeholders, and first responders," adding that "context is necessary... It was a well-attended barbeque with food sources from the farm host, a proudly King company using 100% Canadian meat." The party said the expenses reflect "appreciation events for volunteers and (riding association) members, which may include community barbecues and dinners."

Rippling effects

Noah Jarvis, Ontario director of the Canadian Taxpayers Federation, told the Star that "even if there are disputes, they bring into question how our political parties are using taxpayer money," noting that the political donation tax credit is "more generous than the one you get when donating to a charitable organization." His conclusion: "Parties really need to treat this money respectfully. Taxpayers are giving them that money, not just donors."

Liberal interim leader John Fraser compared the filings to "reading the lifestyles of the rich and famous. They're living pretty high off the hog," and added that "whether it's donor money or taxpayer money, there are too many people using it as their personal piggy bank."

The reporting lands in a season already defined by expense questions around this government, including the MPP hotel expense scandal. The recurring pattern is not any single receipt but a category of spending that is disclosed in aggregate and not in detail.

Elections Ontario filings are the public's main window into riding association finances, and the Star's second report on the filings — covering oyster dinners and luxury beef bills — notes expenses including nearly $15,000 for organic grass-fed premium beef, funded by donations that qualify for provincial tax credits.

Because the reports record what was spent and where but not who was present or what was decided, the filings cannot answer the question they invite. The Star's own reporting notes that the records do not reveal who attended the meetings or who, if anyone, benefited.

Sources

  1. Progressive Conservative party defends cabinet minister's riding association spending — Toronto Star
  2. What $3,400 oyster dinners and luxury beef bills reveal about spending by some Ontario PC riding associations — Toronto Star
↑↓ move↵ focus⌘↵ open page→ start a path from here