Skip to content
Independent · Sourced

Bill 5 — Repealing Environmental Protections and Creating Law-Free Zones for Developers

TL;DR

Under cover of a tariff emergency, Doug Ford passed omnibus legislation that repealed Ontario's Endangered Species Act, created law-free "special economic zones" where cabinet can suspend any provincial rule for handpicked companies, and quietly cancelled environmental assessments for a landfill owned by $200,000 PC donors — repeating the exact playbook of the Greenbelt scandal with no limits and no oversight.

What was promised

Partly kept

Ford's 2025 PC platform promised to ban Chinese components from all future Ontario energy procurements

“Keeping the province’s energy supply secure by banning Chinese components from all future energy procurements. This includes banning any Chinese state-owned enterprise from buying or taking equity in any Ontario government funded energy, critical mineral or major infrastructure asset.”

2025 PC platform, · PC platform, Our Plan to Protect Ontario

What happened · Apr 30, 2026

The government passed a law in June 2025 giving itself the power to restrict foreign energy suppliers, but as of April 2026 no regulation had been made and major power procurements went ahead with no ban on Chinese components.

Ford announced the ban on February 10, 2025, saying "we'll ban Chinese components from future procurements to keep our grid secure." After the election, Bill 5 (the Protect Ontario by Unleashing our Economy Act, 2025) received royal assent on June 5, 2025. It gave the energy minister power to limit foreign participation in the energy sector by regulation or directive, including by the geographic origin of goods and services. The government's own description of the power is limiting "foreign jurisdictions, such as foreign state-owned entities", without naming China. In June 2025 the minister directed the IESO to give a scoring advantage to Canadian-owned bidders in the first window of its LT2 power procurement. That directive did not bar Chinese components. The Ministry of Energy and Mines consulted on possible restrictions in the fall of 2025, and Bill 40 (royal assent December 11, 2025) let utilities record the cost of complying with any future restrictions. Torys LLP reported in December 2025 that no draft regulation had been released. In April 2026 Torys reported that the country-of-origin regulations had still not been enacted. The April 30, 2026 directive launching the Long Lead-Time procurement added Canadian-content disclosure and incentives but no ban on Chinese components.

Partly kept

Ford's environment minister said science would keep deciding which species are endangered

“The federal act allows the Minister of the Environment to make decisions about timelines and to decide which species are endangered. Mr. Species—Mr. Speaker, in Ontario, science will remain the driving feature of which species are endangered.”

Environment Minister Rod Phillips, · Question Period, Legislative Assembly (Hansard)

What happened · Jun 5, 2025

The Auditor General found in 2021 that the 2019 changes to Ontario's species classification criteria were inconsistent with the science-based criteria used in other provinces, and Bill 5 (2025) ended automatic protection for species the science committee COSSARO classifies, though COSSARO still does the classifying.

In 2019, while defending the Endangered Species Act changes later passed in Bill 108, Environment Minister Rod Phillips contrasted Ontario with the federal law, under which a minister decides which species are endangered, and said science would stay the deciding factor in Ontario. In November 2021, Auditor General Bonnie Lysyk reported that the 2019 changes to how Ontario classifies species were inconsistent with the science-based criteria used in other provinces and could cost some species existing protections. She also found that six members were appointed to the species assessment committee without the standard screening process. Bill 5, which took effect June 5, 2025, decoupled legal protection from the science committee's (COSSARO's) classifications. Under the Species Conservation Act, in force since March 30, 2026, cabinet sets the Protected Species in Ontario list by regulation. That list drops aquatic species and migratory birds that COSSARO had classified, and a July 2026 Ontario Nature report found 106 species lost provincial protection.

Who benefited

  • Silvio De Gasperis

    As owner of TACC Construction and a major landowner along the Highway 413 corridor, De Gasperis is a direct beneficiary of Bill 5's repeal of Ontario's Endangered Species Act. Provincial habitat protections for the redside dace and other at-risk species in 11 waterways along the 413 route were eliminated by the bill, removing the primary species-based obstacle to corridor construction.

  • York1 Environmental Waste Solutions Ltd.

    Bill 5 (Protect Ontario by Unleashing our Economy Act, 2025), which received Royal Assent June 5, 2025, revoked Ontario Regulation 284/24 (which had designated York1's Dresden-area landfill project for a full environmental assessment) and amended the Environmental Assessment Act to exempt the project from further EA requirements — the first landfill proposal in the province selected for fast-tracking under Bill 5.

  • Wyloo Ring of Fire Ltd. (Wyloo Metals)

    Bill 5 removed the comprehensive environmental assessment requirement for Wyloo's proposed Eagle's Nest Ring of Fire mine, terminating the voluntary agreement and revoking the 2015 terms of reference, so the project proceeds without a comprehensive assessment (Environmental Registry notice; iPolitics).

    Source: Addressing Changes to the Eagle's Nest Mine Project — Environmental Registry of Ontario, Most advanced Ring of Fire mine to proceed without impact assessment — iPolitics

Connections graph

Key: People Related scandals

The web

10 people
Show 4 more

Why it matters

Bill 5 was framed as an emergency response to U.S. tariffs, but its contents reflect a long-standing deregulation agenda. It was introduced on a Thursday before a long weekend to minimize scrutiny. Bill 5 is an omnibus bill touching 10 statutes — environmental assessment, mining, heritage, energy, endangered species — making it impossible for any single committee or affected community to mount a comprehensive response before committee hearings closed. The Narwhal's breakdown of Bill 5 catalogued the scope of changes that received almost no public deliberation.

The repeal of the Endangered Species Act is the most consequential environmental rollback in Ontario in 18 years. Under the new Species Conservation Act, cabinet — not the scientific Committee on the Status of Species at Risk in Ontario — decides which species get protected. The minister can direct COSSARO to reconsider its scientific findings. The habitat definition was gutted from forests, wetlands, and feeding grounds to just "the nest, den, or immediate area." Companies can begin construction by self-registration, without any government review. A 2021 Auditor General report had already found that permits to harm protected species increased 6,000%+ since 2009 and the province had never denied a single application. Ecojustice documented how Bill 5 made those failures permanent and removed the obligation to explain them.

The Special Economic Zones Act is the most constitutionally unprecedented element. Cabinet can designate any location in Ontario as an SEZ and suspend any provincial law, provincial regulation, or municipal bylaw for entities it designates "trusted proponents." There are no criteria for designation, no public registry, no time limits, and no independent oversight. Ecojustice lawyer Lindsay Beck described it as "an abdication of the legislative role... and when you get to that point of abdication, that's unconstitutional." The notwithstanding clause does not shield this provision from a Section 92 constitutional challenge. Billy Bishop Airport was designated Ontario's first SEZ in early 2026. A constitutional challenge launched in April 2026 targets this provision specifically.

The York 1 landfill element — buried in Schedule 3 — is the most nakedly transactional. The government had promised a full environmental assessment for the Dresden-area landfill during a provincial byelection. Bill 5 cancelled that promise. The landfill's owners, the Guizzetti brothers and their business partner Brian Brunetti, along with executives from their companies, donated over $200,000 to PC causes since 2018 — including over 50 executives donating exactly $945 each, consistent with ticketed fundraising events. Liberal MPP Ted Hsu filed a complaint with the Integrity Commissioner. The Commissioner declined to investigate but explicitly stated she made "no findings about the underlying facts" and had "no information about why the government found it important to advance this particular landfill." That non-decision is not an exoneration. The Trillium documented the full donor connections in detail.

The pattern in Bill 5 — discretionary ministerial power, no criteria, connected proponents, cancelled oversight — is identical to the mechanisms documented in the Greenbelt scandal, MZO scandal, and Skills Development Fund scandal. Critics including Democracy Watch and the Narwhal note that the Special Economic Zones provision is the Greenbelt mechanism writ large: it applies province-wide, to any law, for any proponent the minister chooses to trust. A CBC News guide to Bill 5 laid out how each schedule compounds the others into a governance system with almost no external accountability.

Rippling effects

Two constitutional challenges are active as of April 2026. Fourteen Treaty 9 First Nations filed in Ontario Superior Court in July 2025 seeking to strike down both Bill 5 and the federal Bill C-5, with $100M in damages and an injunction. Their grounds include Charter rights violations (life, liberty, security, equality), the Crown's duty of honourable dealing, and UNDRIP. Global News reported on the original filing; by December 2025, Indigenous grassroots interveners from Attawapiskat First Nation had also sought standing. CP24 covered the July 2025 filing as it happened.

A second constitutional challenge was filed April 8, 2026 by Wildlands League, Environmental Defence Canada, Friends of the Earth Canada, and Democracy Watch, represented by Ecojustice. This challenge targets the Special Economic Zones Act specifically, arguing it unconstitutionally delegates legislative powers to the executive in violation of Section 92 of the Constitution Act. Because the notwithstanding clause does not apply to Section 92 arguments, Bill 5's existing protections cannot shield this provision. No hearing date has been set. CBC News and Global News both covered the April 2026 filing.

Highway 413 construction began in August 2025. Bill 5's repeal of the Endangered Species Act removed provincial habitat protections for the redside dace — an endangered minnow that lost 81% of its population between 2007 and 2017 — in 11 waterways along the corridor. The Narwhal documented how the species' remaining protection depends entirely on federal Species at Risk Act critical habitat orders that Ford has repeatedly pressured Ottawa to remove. A November 2024 report by Canada's Commissioner of the Environment and Sustainable Development warned federal SAR capacity is already insufficient to meet biodiversity commitments.

The Eagle's Nest multi-metal mine environmental assessment — agreed to by Noront Resources in 2011 and continued by acquiring company Wyloo Metals (now Ring of Fire Metals) — was formally terminated by Bill 5. The Ring of Fire region sits atop the Hudson Bay Lowlands, one of the largest carbon-storing peatland systems in North America. Over 40,000 mining claims are staked in the area, a 60%+ jump since 2022. Wyloo is proceeding toward construction starting 2027 and production by 2030, with no comprehensive environmental assessment process. Norton Rose Fulbright and DLA Piper both published legal analyses of the assessment termination's implications for mining investors.

Ontario's retreat from species protection has forced an unprecedented reliance on federal Species at Risk Act capacity that does not exist. Ontario hosts 242 species at risk; 54 federal SARA species have no provincial protection equivalent. Endangered species recovery plans for the eastern wolf, northern oak hairstreak butterfly, and three migratory bat species were completed by the ministry after Bill 5's passage — and then actively suppressed from public posting (documented in the connected scandal). The Billy Bishop Airport SEZ designation creates a template for circumventing municipal planning in dense urban contexts, with no criteria established to prevent the designation from being extended to any politically convenient location. Ecojustice's analysis describes the compounding effect across all of Bill 5's schedules as "a governance architecture designed to insulate decisions from scrutiny."

Linked bills

Sources

  1. After passing Bill 5, Ford government asked staff for suggestions on how to use law — Global News
  2. Bill 5, Protect Ontario by Unleashing our Economy Act, 2025 — Legislative Assembly of Ontario
  3. Bill 5 explained: What Ontario's omnibus legislation does — The Narwhal
  4. Ontario's Special Economic Zones explained — The Narwhal
  5. What Bill 5 would do — CBC News
  6. First Nations launch legal challenge against Ontario Bill 5 — CBC News
  7. Environmental groups launch constitutional challenge over Ontario's Special Economic Zones — CBC News
  8. How Bill 5 guts environmental protections — Ecojustice
  9. First Nations file legal challenge against Ontario Bill 5 — Global News
  10. Environmental groups launch constitutional challenge over Bill 5 — Global News
  11. Ford says Bill 5 SEZ powers no longer needed for Ring of Fire — Global News
  12. 'It stinks': Ford government's Dresden dump flip-flop favours big PC donors — The Trillium
  13. Integrity Commissioner declines to investigate Ford ministers over Dresden landfill u-turn — The Trillium
  14. Integrity Commissioner rules 'insufficient grounds' to probe Ford, ministers over Dresden landfill — CBC News
  15. Construction starting on Highway 413: How Bill 5 changes the landscape — The Narwhal
  16. Ontario won't share recovery plans for endangered species — The Narwhal
  17. Bill 5, Protect Ontario by Unleashing our Economy Act, 2025 receives royal assent — Norton Rose Fulbright
  18. What foreign mining investors should know about Ontario Bill 5 — DLA Piper
  19. Ontario is making little effort to protect at-risk species from building and resource development: Auditor General
  20. First Nations launch legal challenge against Ontario and federal Bill C-5 — CP24
  21. Stop Bill 5 — Environmental Defence Canada
  22. Bill 5 campaign — Ontario Nature
  23. 2024 Commissioner of the Environment and Sustainable Development Report — Office of the Auditor General of Canada
  24. Ontario's Species Conservation Act comes into force, eliminating recovery plan requirements — The Narwhal
  25. Over 100 species at risk lose protection under Ontario's Species Conservation Act — Ontario Nature
  26. Ontario's own biologists warned against species-at-risk changes — The Narwhal (May 25, 2026)
  27. The Impact of Bill 5 on Species — Ontario Nature
  28. Bill 5: Dismantling Ontario's Environmental Safeguards — WWF-Canada
  29. Legislative Assembly of Ontario: Bill 140, Building Ontario Faster Act, 2026
  30. Toronto Star: Ford government may force new landfills on communities as Trump tariff targets garbage exports
  31. Ford government hopes to burn more garbage, build more landfills — CityNews (The Canadian Press)
↑↓ move↵ focus⌘↵ open page→ start a path from here