Ford Government Spent $231 Million to Tear Up 758 Renewable Energy Contracts
Up to $231MCost to Ontario
4 sources ↓TL;DR
Weeks after taking office in 2018, the Ford government cancelled 758 renewable energy contracts, including a partly built wind farm in a cabinet minister's riding, and said ratepayers would be protected from the cost. The 2018-19 Public Accounts later showed up to $231 million set aside to wind the contracts down, paid by taxpayers.
Key: People Related scandals
The web
7 peopleShow 1 moreShow fewer
Why it matters
The government sold the cancellations as a saving. Its July 13, 2018 release said Ontario ratepayers would "benefit from $790 million in savings" from the decision to "cancel and wind down 758 renewable energy contracts," and that a legislative amendment would "protect hydro consumers from any costs incurred from the cancellation." Greg Rickford called the projects "unnecessary and wasteful." The announcement did not say which projects were being cancelled, CBC News reported, and the $790 million figure was disputed by industry officials, according to The Canadian Press.
The cost arrived anyway, on a different ledger. The 2018-19 Public Accounts listed $231 million in Ministry of Energy spending under unexplained "other transactions," CBC reported. When officials did not answer an NDP researcher's questions, he asked legislative library staff, and a ministry official replied that costs "associated with the wind down and subsequent termination of renewable energy contracts (including the costs associated with the termination of the White Pines Wind project) are not anticipated to exceed $231 million." Associate Energy Minister Bill Walker acknowledged that taxpayers, not hydro customers, would be on the hook, according to The Canadian Press.
One of the cancelled projects was in a cabinet minister's riding. The White Pines wind farm in Prince Edward County, developed by wpd Canada, is in the riding of Todd Smith, then the PC MPP for Bay of Quinte and minister of children, community and social services. Four of its nine approved turbines were built in 2018 before the new government issued a stop-work order, and crews were dismantling them by November 2019, CBC reported. CBC also reported that the PCs had said cancelling the project would not cost taxpayers. "This municipality was an unwilling host from day one. They did not want the turbines. We did the right thing," Walker told the legislature.
The people hurt were not only large developers. John Gorman, president of the Canadian Solar Industries Association, called the decision "rash" and told CBC News it would hit "small rooftop projects that are owned by farmers and school boards and municipalities and First Nations groups," and "the installers and contractors and the engineers."
Rippling effects
The NDP compared the cost to the Liberal gas plant scandal. "Wasting $231 million to cancel hydro contracts is the sort of thing the previous Liberal government did during the gas plant scandal," NDP energy critic Peter Tabuns said, according to CBC News. Walker, in turn, pointed to the Liberal gas plant cancellations, which the auditor general put at upwards of $1 billion.
The final bill was left open. The government said the final figure, including decommissioning White Pines, had yet to be established, and a spokeswoman for Rickford said decommissioning was still ongoing, The Canadian Press reported. In 2018 wpd Canada said the wind farm had been under development for nearly a decade and warned that the dispute could be headed to the courts, according to CBC News.
Critics warned the move would damage Ontario's reputation with investors. Green Party Leader Mike Schreiner asked, "What does it say to those investors when Ontario is ripping those kind of contracts up?" Interim Liberal Leader John Fraser said tearing up contracts was "costing money and hurting our reputation" (The Canadian Press). Paying to get out of a signed deal would come up again with the government's cancelled Starlink contract.
Sources
- Ontario to Cancel Energy Contracts to Bring Hydro Bills Down — Ontario Newsroom
- Ontario government cancels 758 renewable energy contracts, says it will save millions — CBC News
- Doug Ford government spent $231M to scrap green energy projects — CBC News
- Ford government's cancellation of green energy deals costs Ontario $231 million — Global News / The Canadian Press





