Skip to content
Independent · Sourced

"Black Thursday": Ford Cancels the French-Language University and Eliminates the French Language Services Commissioner

TL;DR

In its November 15, 2018 fiscal update, the Ford government cancelled the planned Université de l'Ontario français and eliminated the French Language Services Commissioner, a day Franco-Ontarians came to call "Black Thursday." The backlash drove PC MPP Amanda Simard out of caucus and thousands into the streets, and the government partly retreated: the commissioner was folded into the Ombudsman's office and the university was saved through a funding deal with Ottawa.

Connections graph

Key: People Related scandals

Why it matters

In a single day the fiscal update cut a planned university and the language-rights watchdog serving more than 600,000 French speakers in Ontario. Doug Ford announced that his government would cancel the planned French-language university in Toronto and eliminate the French Language Services Commissioner, CBC News reported. "The French university was more than just a French university. It's a symbol for the province, and it was a fantastic step forward," said Carol Jolin, president of the Assemblée de la francophonie de l'Ontario (AFO).

The university was a campaign promise. The Globe and Mail reported that Ford had promised during the election campaign to keep plans for a francophone university, then said there was not enough money in the province for one. The government said the cuts were needed to deal with what it called a $15-billion deficit. Jolin said he felt Ford was walking back campaign promises to the francophone community: "It is an attack on francophones, when you look at all the decisions being made.... And we are afraid that more is coming."

The partial retreat did not restore what was cut. Days after the announcement, the government said it would create a French-language services commissioner position under the Ombudsman's office, and Ford formally installed Attorney General Caroline Mulroney as Minister of Francophone Affairs. According to the federal Office of the Commissioner of Official Languages, the commissioner and his office were eliminated and, on May 1, 2019, the position became part of the Office of the Ombudsman of Ontario. The university was not revived.

The cuts became a national issue. Prime Minister Justin Trudeau said he was "deeply disappointed by the decision of the Ontario government to cut services and protections for the francophone minorities in Ontario," and federal official languages minister Mélanie Joly asked to meet the Ford government. Quebec Premier François Legault said he wanted French in Ontario "to be protected as much as possible" and, CBC later reported, asked Ford to reconsider when they met. Federal Conservative leader Andrew Scheer conveyed his concerns to Ford and Mulroney, CBC reported.

Rippling effects

The government lost a member of its own caucus. On November 21, PC MPP Amanda Simard wrote that the decisions "disappoint me greatly," said she had first worked internally to reverse them, and told Franco-Ontarians, "You have an ally in me, and I will never let you down," CBC reported. She called the government's partial backtracking not enough and voted against the fiscal update. On November 29, 2018, she left the PC caucus to sit as an independent, CBC and the Globe reported. Ford said she had stopped returning his office's calls and that the party was "more united than we've ever been."

Franco-Ontarians mobilized. The AFO announced a day of action on December 1, 2018, with rallies planned in some 40 locations, and the Commissioner of Official Languages records that thousands of people demonstrated across the province that day against what Franco-Ontarians saw as a language crisis.

The university was eventually saved with federal money. In September 2019, Ontario and the federal government reached an agreement to jointly fund the French-language university that Ford's government had scrapped. Under the memorandum of understanding, Ottawa's share would not exceed 50 per cent of Ontario's costs; Global News reported the province had secured half the funding for the project, estimated at $126 million.

The episode still appears on lists of Ford reversals. Both a 2019 Global News roundup and a 2024 Canadian Press list of policies and cuts the government walked back include the French-language university, noting that the cancellation sparked an outcry among Franco-Ontarians and prompted a Progressive Conservative caucus member to quit.

Sources

  1. Trudeau 'deeply disappointed' by cuts to Ontario French services — CBC News
  2. Ontario PC MPP blasts Ford government's cuts to French-language services — CBC News
  3. MPP Amanda Simard leaving PCs, will sit as independent — CBC News
  4. Ontario MPP Amanda Simard quits PC caucus after cuts to francophone services — The Globe and Mail
  5. "Black Thursday" rocks the Franco-Ontarian community — Office of the Commissioner of Official Languages
  6. Ontario, federal governments reach 'understanding' on funding French-language university — Global News
  7. List of cuts, program changes Doug Ford government has reversed — Global News
  8. A list of policies and cuts the Doug Ford government has reversed — The Canadian Press (via Cornwall Seaway News)
↑↓ move↵ focus⌘↵ open page→ start a path from here