Skip to content
Independent · Sourced

Ford Cancels the Hamilton LRT Over a Disputed $5.5 Billion Price Tag, Then Revives It 17 Months Later

TL;DR

In December 2019 the Ford government cancelled the Hamilton LRT it had promised to build, claiming it would cost $5.5 billion, a figure that included almost $2 billion in operating and maintenance costs. In May 2021 the province and Ottawa revived the same 14-kilometre line under a nearly $3.4 billion federal-provincial deal.

Connections graph

Key: People Related scandals

Why it matters

The cancellation broke a campaign promise, and the $5.5 billion figure used to justify it counted costs that the original $1 billion figure did not. Mulroney said a third party hired by the government had determined the LRT would cost "an astonishing $5.5 billion," and alleged the Liberals and former transportation minister Steven Del Duca "were not upfront" about it, CBC News reported. But CBC also reported that the provincial estimate included almost $2 billion in costs like operating and maintenance over the project's lifespan, while the original $1 billion figure was only the capital cost of building it. Asked whether the province had added those costs to justify the cancellation, Mulroney said: "We aren't trying to kill the project... But it's clear the numbers we inherited misrepresented the true cost of the project."

The government's case rested on the claim that the Liberals had hidden the real cost. Mulroney said the province learned after taking office that the previous government "was privately expecting the total cost of the project to exceed $3 billion," and that the Liberals "misled the people of Hamilton and all Ontarians," Global News reported. Doug Ford said: "Not our fault, they can look at the previous government and ask them why they lied." He added that unless the mayor found "another $3.6 billion on the backs of the people of Hamilton," the city would have to choose another project. NDP Leader Andrea Horwath, a Hamilton MPP, said "what this premier likes to do is make up numbers to justify their cuts" (CBC).

Hamilton officials say the province gave them little information. Mayor Fred Eisenberger told Global News that at his first meeting on the project the province wanted him to sign a non-disclosure agreement, which he refused, and that the only sign of trouble was a "one-pager" on projects whose costs had escalated. The city's LRT project head told CBC his staff had asked the province to say if the project was over budget so they could talk about where to trim it, and "we never really received anything."

Public money had already gone into the line. CBC reported that Metrolinx had spent $162 million on it. The Hamilton Chamber of Commerce said the province had spent $184 million developing the line and another $80 million on property over the past decade, accusing the premier of reneging on a "repeated, firm commitment" (CityNews/The Canadian Press).

Rippling effects

Eisenberger said about 40 employees funded by Metrolinx would lose their jobs and that the three consortiums short-listed to design, build, finance, operate and maintain the system had been told to "park their pens," CBC reported. Two city councillors refused to leave the lobby of the building where Mulroney had relocated until they could hear the technical briefing, and the property manager called police.

The province said the $1 billion would stay available for transportation in Hamilton and set up a task force to recommend alternative projects by the end of February 2020 (Global News). Eisenberger said he had not received confirmation that the money could be used for public transit.

Seventeen months later the line was back. On May 13, 2021, federal ministers and Caroline Mulroney announced a deal to invest nearly $3.4 billion in the Hamilton LRT, with each government paying 50 per cent of eligible costs up to $1.7 billion and Ontario covering the project's life-cycle costs, according to the Government of Canada release. The revived project is the same 14-kilometre, 17-stop line from McMaster University to Eastgate that the province cancelled in 2019.

Sources

  1. Ontario cancels Hamilton LRT in chaotic announcement; mayor calls it a 'betrayal' — CBC News
  2. Ontario government cancels Hamilton LRT project, mayor calls it a betrayal — Global News
  3. Ontario cancels Hamilton light rail project in what mayor calls a 'betrayal' — CityNews / The Canadian Press
  4. Federal government and Province commit to shovel-ready Hamilton Light Rail Transit project from McMaster to Eastgate at Centennial Park — Infrastructure Canada
↑↓ move↵ focus⌘↵ open page→ start a path from here