Skills Development Fund — $750M Patronage Scandal
$1BCost to Ontario
32 sources ↓TL;DR
Ontario's Auditor General found that $750 million in Skills Development Fund grants were awarded in a process that was "not fair, transparent or accountable." Ford's own campaign manager Kory Teneycke runs a lobbying firm whose clients received over $100 million — nearly 3x any other firm. The Premier's nephew's former chief of staff registered as a lobbyist immediately after leaving the Premier's office, and his clients received grants. Labour Minister David Piccini's office overrode civil servants' recommendations in over half of cases reviewed.
Who benefited
- Keel Digital Solutions · $7.5M grant / $25M+ lawsuit
Keel Digital Solutions received a $7.5-million Skills Development Fund grant for a digital mental-health peer-counselling platform for Peel Region police and officer training. A subsequent forensic audit of the company's separate Ministry of Colleges and Universities contract found apparent irregularities in transfer payments to its subsidiary Get A-Head, which the Ford government referred to the OPP Anti-Rackets Branch for investigation; Ontario later sued the company for over $25 million alleging fraudulent misrepresentation, and the company filed a $98-million countersuit denying wrongdoing.
- Jay Fischbach
COO of Keel Digital Solutions, a Skills Development Fund grant recipient. National Bank of Canada has applied in the Ontario Superior Court of Justice to place Keel and two associated corporations under BDO Canada Limited as receiver, alleging over $4.5 million borrowed, events of default, and that the companies "diverted their banking activity to TD Bank." Fischbach responded: "there was no diverting of funds and we fully intend to repay National Bank all funds owed from our loan." The allegations have not been tested in court and no order had been granted as of August 30, 2026.
- Merit Openshop · ~$5M combined (rounds 4–5)
Received SDF grants from rounds one through five, including roughly $5 million combined from rounds four and five. Per The Trillium's analysis, its CEO, Michael Gallardo, gave over $15,000 to PC Party causes from 2015 to 2024. According to Ministry of Labour records disclosed through freedom of information and reported by The Trillium (Sept. 17, 2026), it was among recipients of third-round SDF grants that had not submitted reports before receiving subsequent funding. The records do not explain why. The labour minister's office says the ministry checked in on recipients in other ways and that some eventually delivered their results; spokesperson Michel Figueredo said every agreement includes "mandatory activity reports, strict financial controls, including third-party audits." No wrongdoing is alleged against the recipient.
- Hammer Heads · $1.5M+ each (rounds 4 and 5)
Received SDF funding in the first three rounds under Monte McNaughton, then fourth- and fifth-round grants of over $1.5 million apiece awarded by David Piccini. Per The Trillium's analysis, the manager of the group that runs Hammer Heads gave almost $10,000 to PC Party causes from 2019 to 2025, including over $2,000 to McNaughton's riding association while he was in charge of the fund. According to Ministry of Labour records disclosed through freedom of information and reported by The Trillium (Sept. 17, 2026), it was among recipients of third-round SDF grants that had not submitted reports before receiving subsequent funding. The records do not explain why. The labour minister's office says the ministry checked in on recipients in other ways and that some eventually delivered their results; spokesperson Michel Figueredo said every agreement includes "mandatory activity reports, strict financial controls, including third-party audits." No wrongdoing is alleged against the recipient.
- LiUNA Local 506 Training Centre · $2.6M+ combined (rounds 4–5)
Awarded grants from most rounds of the SDF, including over $2.6 million combined from rounds four and five. According to Ministry of Labour records disclosed through freedom of information and reported by The Trillium (Sept. 17, 2026), it was among recipients of third-round SDF grants that had not submitted reports before receiving subsequent funding. The records do not explain why. The labour minister's office says the ministry checked in on recipients in other ways and that some eventually delivered their results; spokesperson Michel Figueredo said every agreement includes "mandatory activity reports, strict financial controls, including third-party audits." No wrongdoing is alleged against the recipient.
- Scooty Mobility · $1M grant (score 42/100)
According to an internal ministry database obtained by the Toronto Star (November 14, 2025), Scooty Mobility scored 42 and was given $1 million to teach 100 workers about the "transformative impact of AI in fintech." Ministry staff cited "no prior experience" and said there were "more risks to the application than strengths"; the "minister's rationale" cited community partners and recruitment of under-represented workers. The Star reports Scooty hired two lobbyists with Tory connections, including former Ford staffer David DiPaul. Piccini's spokesperson said Scooty has "extensive experience" in AI and fintech. Scooty's CEO did not respond to the Star.
- Postmedia · $1.04M grant (score 41.68/100)
According to an internal ministry database obtained by the Toronto Star (November 14, 2025), Postmedia's application scored 41.68 and received $1.04 million for artificial-intelligence staff training (to train 130 journalists and other staff). Evaluators cited an "unclear" budget allocation, no in-house contributions and "negative media attention." Postmedia said it applied "through the open, government-overseen process" and was not aware of any scores.
- Carpenters District Council of Ontario (Carpenters' Regional Council) · $14M training stream (+ up to $13M capital)
Received a $14 million Skills Development Fund training grant (plus up to $13 million in the capital stream) despite a 52% ministry score; the Star reports the application awaited the minister's signature, and the council's leaders praised Ford in PC campaign literature.
Source: Secret data reveals which low-scoring applicants still received millions of dollars — Toronto Star, Carpenters' Union Receives Record-breaking $14 Million — Carpenters' Regional Council via CNW (Jan 24, 2025)
- Operating Engineers Training Institute of Ontario (IUOE Local 793) · $7.419M
Received $7.419 million from the Skills Development Fund for training equipment despite a ministry score of 43; evaluators flagged that it 'will not benefit any job seekers' (Toronto Star).
Source: Secret data reveals which low-scoring applicants still received millions of dollars — Toronto Star
- KE Electrical · $2.7M
Awarded $2.7 million from the Skills Development Fund to train Ottawa-area job seekers despite a ministry score of 40 (Toronto Star).
Source: Secret data reveals which low-scoring applicants still received millions of dollars — Toronto Star
- Ontario Shipyards (formerly Heddle Shipyards) · $22.4M over three rounds (from 2022)
Received Skills Development Fund grants in three consecutive rounds starting in 2022, totalling $22.4 million per Labour Ministry records; Ford announced the third, $10 million, at its St. Catharines yard on August 21, 2024. A client of Rubicon Strategy, owned by PC campaign manager Kory Teneycke. Its executives and directors have given over $55,000 to PC causes since 2021. In February 2026 Ford publicly urged Ottawa to give it a navy shipbuilding contract (The Trillium).
Source: Premier Ford urging feds to give major shipbuilding contract to company his campaign manager's firm lobbies for — The Trillium, Labour minister has given PC donor-led companies 80% of for-profit businesses' Skills Development Funds — The Trillium
Key: People Related scandals
The web
13 peopleShow 7 moreShow fewer
Why it matters
The most striking finding involves Kory Teneycke — Doug Ford's own campaign manager for the 2018, 2022, and 2024 provincial elections, and the person most credited with Ford's electoral success. Teneycke owns Rubicon Strategy, a government relations firm. Rubicon's clients received over $100 million in SDF grants — nearly three times the next highest-performing lobbying firm. Teneycke simultaneously manages Ford's political campaigns and operates a lobbying business whose clients are funded by Ford government programs. This conflict of interest was not disclosed to applicants or to the public during the program's operation.
David DiPaul, who served as chief of staff to Michael Ford — the Premier's nephew and a Ford cabinet minister — registered as a lobbyist in June 2024, immediately after leaving the Premier's nephew's office. His clients subsequently received SDF grants. The revolving door between the Premier's family's offices and the lobbying industry — with the SDF program as the financial intermediary — demonstrates the systemic nature of the problem: it is not one bad actor but a network operating with apparent impunity.
The Auditor General's findings on the SDF mirror the documented pattern from the Greenbelt scandal: insider access to political staff determines outcomes, while the formal merit-based process is treated as advisory or easily overridden. In the Greenbelt case, Housing Minister Steve Clark's chief of staff directed billions in land-value windfalls to politically connected developers. In the SDF case, the Labour Minister's office directed hundreds of millions in grants to clients of the Premier's campaign manager. In both cases, the independent audit process caught what the government's own controls did not prevent.
Legal actions
Ontario's Auditor General Shelley Spence released a special report in October 2025 finding that over $750 million in Skills Development Fund grants were awarded through a process that was "not fair, transparent or accountable." The report found that the Labour Minister's office overrode civil servants' recommendations in more than half of cases, that low-scoring applications backed by politically connected lobbyists received funding while higher-scoring applications were rejected, and that one application scored 41% and flagged for conflicts of interest was funded anyway. The AG recommended systemic reforms to application processes, conflict-of-interest controls, and ministerial oversight.
Integrity Commissioner Investigation into Labour Minister David Piccini (opens in a new tab)
In ProgressFollowing the Auditor General's findings, Ontario's Integrity Commissioner opened a formal investigation into Labour Minister David Piccini over his office's role in directing SDF grants against the recommendations of non-partisan civil servants. Opposition parties called for Piccini's resignation. The investigation was ongoing as of early 2026, with no findings publicly released. The Commissioner's jurisdiction covers whether Piccini breached the Members' Integrity Act in the exercise of his ministerial powers.
At least one SDF grant recipient — Keel Digital Solutions — was referred to the OPP for criminal investigation following an audit of its grant usage. Keel had received a Skills Development Fund grant, and the audit found irregularities sufficient to warrant a police referral. The specifics of the referral were not fully disclosed by the government. The OPP investigation was ongoing as of early 2026. Critics noted the referral illustrated that the SDF's oversight failures were not merely administrative but potentially criminal in specific cases.
Ontario filed a statement of claim in Ontario Superior Court seeking $25.7 million in damages plus $100,000 punitive damages per defendant executive against Keel Digital Solutions Corp. and its subsidiary Get A-Head Inc. The province alleges the company inflated performance metrics by more than tenfold, billed for ineligible expenses including first-class airfare and fine dining, and retained unspent public funds as profit. Get A-Head received approximately $40 million in provincial funding over five years, including $7.5 million directly from the Skills Development Fund. A forensic audit completed in November 2025 and an OPP investigation are running in parallel.
The Ontario Provincial Police launched a criminal investigation in parallel with the civil lawsuit against Keel Digital Solutions and its subsidiary Get A-Head Inc., following the completion of a forensic audit in November 2025 that found evidence of inflated reporting and misappropriation of provincial funds.
Keel Digital Solutions Corp. filed a $98 million countersuit against Ontario after the province sued Keel for $25.7 million alleging fraud in the Skills Development Fund. Keel alleges its reputation was damaged by the province's public statements and legal action. The countersuit creates significant legal risk that Ontario may be required to disclose internal documents about how funding decisions were made, including any communications involving political staff.
National Bank of Canada has filed an application with Ontario's Superior Court seeking an order placing Keel Digital Solutions and a pair of corporations associated with it under the control of BDO Canada Limited as receiver. If granted, the receiver would try to trace and safeguard the companies' assets so National Bank and other creditors could be repaid.
The bank's lawyers claim the companies borrowed over $4.5 million and "committed certain events of default," including stopping interest payments and "ceasing to carry on business or a substantial portion thereof." The bank also argued a receivership is necessary because the companies "diverted their banking activity to TD Bank, leaving (National Bank) with no visibility as to the Respondents' operations."
Jay Fischbach, Keel Digital's chief operating officer, said in an email that "there was no diverting of funds and we fully intend to repay National Bank all funds owed from our loan," and that Keel has banked with TD for years and continues to.
National Bank cites the province's ongoing case against Keel, claiming the companies have "lost their primary source of income and have no material customers" now that Ontario cancelled its contracts, alleged fraud, and sued for about $26 million. Keel countersued the province for $100 million. The next hearing date in that case is in October 2026.
Alfonso Nocilla, an associate dean at Western University's faculty of law, reviewed the application and said that if the claims are accurate the bank would likely succeed, because the companies breached their loan agreements. He said a receiver would have broad powers to trace funds, would decide whether to continue the countersuit against the province, and that the province would likely not be first in line for repayment.
None of the allegations by either side, or by National Bank, have been tested in court. The Trillium, July 29, 2026.
Receivership order granted, Oct. 5, 2026. On Monday, October 5, 2026, Ontario Superior Court Justice Jane Dietrich granted National Bank's application and placed Keel Digital Solutions into receivership under BDO Canada Limited. Neither Keel nor its executives objected, and they did not contest the bank's claim that the company cannot repay more than $4.5 million. Keel's lawyer told the court the company had put several settlement scenarios to the province, each of which would have repaid National Bank in full, but no settlement was reached. The receiver will now decide whether to pursue Keel's countersuit against the province. Source: The Trillium, Oct. 5, 2026.
Rippling effects
The Skills Development Fund scandal matters beyond its immediate dollar figures. Training programs are supposed to help the workers who need it most — those being displaced by automation, those without post-secondary credentials, those in declining industries. When the selection process is captured by lobbyists with political connections, the workers who benefit from grants are those whose employers can afford Rubicon Strategy retainers, not those most in need of retraining support.
The Integrity Commissioner and OPP investigations remain active as of early 2026. If criminal charges arise from the Keel Digital Solutions referral or the broader investigation, this scandal would become the most directly criminal element of the Ford government's record — with the potential to reach the Premier's own campaign infrastructure. Teneycke's role is particularly combustible: as the architect of three Ford election wins, a finding of systematic grant-steering to his clients would blur the line between governance and campaign finance in Ontario in ways that have few recent precedents.
The SDF scandal also reveals the inadequacy of Ontario's lobbying disclosure system. Teneycke's dual role as campaign manager and lobbyist with SDF-funded clients is legal under current rules — illustrating how the formal ethics architecture fails to capture the most significant conflicts of interest in Ontario politics. The Auditor General's report recommended systemic reforms to the application and oversight process, but as of early 2026, the Ford government had not committed to implementing them.
Sources
- Top Labour Ministry aide departs Ford government days after minister shuffled out — Global News
- Ontario's new labour minister says goal with troubled training fund is 'using every dollar wisely' — The Trillium
- Ontario transparency watchdog warns government is dodging its orders — CTV News / CP24
- Ontario's new labour minister says goal with troubled training fund is 'using every dollar wisely' — The Trillium
- CBC — Ontario auditor says skills training funding not fair, transparent or accountable
- Global News — Ford government picked low-scoring lobbyist-backed projects for SDF grants
- The Trillium — Clients of lobby firms connected to Premier and his nephew given tens of millions
- Globe and Mail — Skills Development Fund lobbyists
- CP24 — Auditor General: $750M in grants not fair, transparent or accountable
- CBC — Integrity Commissioner to probe Piccini over Skills Development Fund
- CBC — OPP referral for Keel Digital Solutions SDF audit
- Millions from Ford government training fund went to recipients that hadn't submitted final reports on previous projects — The Trillium
- Ontario sues company in Skills Development Fund controversy for millions in damages — Globe and Mail
- Keel Digital Solutions countersues Ontario for $98M over Skills Development Fund fraud claims — CBC News
- Integrity Commissioner investigating Labour Minister David Piccini over Skills Development Fund — Global News
- Controversial Ontario fund rejected TTC training program with little explanation, documents show — CP24
- Opposition slams expenses at hotels, limo company paid for by Ontario labour minister's constituency association — CP24
- Bank seeks court order to remove company involved in Skills Development Fund scandal from executives' control — Northern Ontario Business / The Trillium
- Bank seeks court order to remove company involved in Skills Development Fund scandal from executives' control — The Trillium
- Ford shuffles cabinet, moves Piccini to Infrastructure amid integrity commissioner investigation — CP24
- Premier Doug Ford shuffles his cabinet — Global News
- Ontario labour ministry violating legal orders to fulfil delayed Skills Development Fund freedom-of-information requests — The Trillium (via BayToday)
- Ontario labour ministry violating legal orders to fulfil delayed Skills Development Fund freedom-of-information requests — The Trillium (via SooToday)
- Secret data reveals which low-scoring applicants still received millions of dollars from the Ford government's skills fund — Toronto Star
- Company at centre of Skills Development Fund scandal ordered into receivership — The Trillium
- Company at centre of Skills Development Fund scandal ordered into receivership — The Trillium (via TimminsToday)
- Ford government says it's tightened rules for next round of skills development funding — Toronto Star
- Groups led by PC donors received majority of recent Ontario training funds — The Trillium
- Company given $2M from Skills Development Fund run by Ford family dentist: sources — The Trillium
- Labour minister has given PC donor-led companies 80% of for-profit businesses' Skills Development Funds — The Trillium
- OPP investigating another group given millions by Ford government — The Trillium
- Premier Ford urging feds to give major shipbuilding contract to company his campaign manager's firm lobbies for — The Trillium












