Ford Government Moves to Repeal the Public's Environmental Bill of Rights Powers, Backdated and Without Compensation
TL;DR
Ford's omnibus red-tape bill, Bill 140, would remove Ontarians' Environmental Bill of Rights powers to request reviews and investigations and to sue over harm to public resources. If passed, the repeal takes effect back to Oct. 27, 2026, the day the bill was tabled, and the bill says no one gets compensation. The bill has had first reading only.
Key: People Related scandals
The web
2 peopleWhy it matters
The Environmental Bill of Rights, 1993 gives Ontarians procedural rights that the government's own consultation notice calls "unique in Canada": the right to ask a ministry to review a law or policy, to ask for an investigation of a suspected environmental offence, and, under Part VI, to sue for harm to a public resource. Schedule 8 of Bill 140 repeals Parts IV to VI, which hold all three.
The repeal is backdated. Schedule 8 says the key sections are deemed to have come into force on the day the bill received first reading, October 27, 2026. If the bill passes, rights that existed on the day it was tabled would be treated as gone from that day. Schedule 8 also adds a clause that no person is entitled to compensation because of it, and lets transition regulations be retroactive.
The public comment period came after the decision to table the bill. ERO notice 026-1109 was posted the same day, October 27, and closes November 26, 2026. The ministry's reasons are that the framework is "largely unchanged since 1994", that some mechanisms can lead to delays in government decisions and create uncertainty for businesses, and that the right to sue is "seldom-used".
The government's news release does not name the EBR repeal. Environment Minister Todd McCarthy said the bill "would modernize environmental oversight, reduce duplication". The same bill exempts the Highway 69 expansion from the Environmental Assessment Act and removes the requirement for municipal support for new landfills.
Rippling effects
If Bill 140 passes, Ontarians lose the formal routes to make a ministry review a law or investigate a suspected offence, and the right to bring an environmental protection action. The repeal is backdated to first reading, and the bill bars compensation.
The changes extend the same environmental-assessment and EBR rollback seen in Bill 5. According to ERO 026-1109, the proposal also repeals third-party leave to appeal under the EBR. Schedule 9 ends third-party appeals to the Ontario Land Tribunal on renewable energy approvals, also back to first reading.
Comments on ERO 026-1109 close November 26, 2026. The bill has had first reading only and has been ordered for second reading.
Sources
- Bill 140, Building Ontario Faster Act, 2026 — Legislative Assembly of Ontario
- Proposed amendments to the Environmental Bill of Rights, 1993 and related amendments to the Environmental Protection Act (ERO 026-1109) — Environmental Registry of Ontario
- Ontario Cutting Permit Processing Times by 220,000 Days to Build the Most Competitive Economy in the G7 — Ontario Newsroom (Oct 27, 2026)
- Environmental Defence: Bill 140 would open the door to corruption by gutting Environmental Bill of Rights
- Ecojustice: Ecojustice call on Ontario government to retract Bill 140
- NOW Toronto: 'It's not just an environmental issue': Advocates warn Ontario bill could limit public input
- Global News: Ford government's Bill 140 gutting Ontario's environmental rights, experts warn
- Globe and Mail: Ontario wobbles on ending municipalities' veto over new landfills
- The Narwhal: How Doug Ford's Bill 140 overhauls recycling and builds more landfills
- Environmental Registry of Ontario 026-1056: Proposed Actions to Address Landfill Capacity

