Craft Kingsmen's $500M Metrolinx Air Rights Shakedown
TL;DR
A company co-led by Ford's close friend and PC Party fundraiser Carmine Nigro extracted an undisclosed settlement from Ontario's public transit agency after claiming $500 million for air rights it never fully paid for — and the Ford government refuses to say how much taxpayers owe.
Who benefited
- Carmine Nigro
President and CEO of Craft Development Corporation, the Ford-connected half of the Craft Kingsmen joint venture that claimed $492.9 million from Metrolinx for expropriated air rights over Union Station. Nigro is a former Vice-Chairman of the PC Ontario Fund and a close personal friend of Premier Ford — seated at Ford's own table at a Ford family wedding in 2022. While his company pursued a half-billion-dollar claim against a provincial agency, Ford had appointed Nigro to chair the LCBO, chair the Ontario Place Redevelopment Corporation, and sit on the board of Invest Ontario. The settlement amount was kept confidential.
- Matthew Castelli
President of Kingsmen Group Inc., which co-founded Craft Kingsmen Rail (East) Corp. with Carmine Nigro's Craft Development Corporation. The JV filed a $492.9M expropriation claim against Metrolinx for Union Station air rights that Craft Kingsmen had agreed to purchase but never completed buying. The case settled confidentially in late 2025.
- Craft Kingsmen Rail (East) Corp. · $500M claim (settlement amount undisclosed)
Craft Kingsmen Rail (East) Corp. had agreed in 2018 to buy roughly 35.5 acres of air rights above rail tracks near Union Station from CN and Toronto Terminals Railway, but had not closed the deal when Metrolinx expropriated the rights in 2021-2022. The company then pursued a $500 million compensation claim at the Ontario Land Tribunal against Metrolinx, arguing it could have built highrise mixed-use towers on the site; the case was settled out of court in late 2025/early 2026 for an undisclosed amount that the province has refused to make public.
- Kingsmen Group Inc. · $500M claim (settlement amount undisclosed)
Kingsmen Group Inc. (led by President Matthew Castelli), together with Craft Development Corporation, formed Craft Kingsmen Rail (East) Corp., which took Metrolinx to the Ontario Land Tribunal seeking roughly $500M in compensation after Metrolinx expropriated 'air rights' above rail lines near Union Station that Craft Kingsmen had agreed to purchase from CN and Toronto Terminals Railway but had not yet closed on. The dispute was settled confidentially, with Premier Ford (a personal friend of the company's principals) and Metrolinx declining to disclose the settlement amount.
Key: People Related scandals
The web
8 peopleShow 2 moreShow fewer
Why it matters
This case sits at the intersection of Ford's most persistent patterns: public assets transferred at undisclosed value to politically connected developers, with confidentiality preventing accountability. Craft Kingsmen claimed a half-billion dollars for air rights it never paid for, over a property Metrolinx argues was not even buildable at the scale claimed. Whatever settlement Metrolinx agreed to is now buried under a confidentiality clause — and Ontarians are paying it.
Carmine Nigro's web of government appointments makes the secrecy more troubling, not less. As Ontario Liberal leader Bonnie Crombie noted, Nigro simultaneously chaired the LCBO (a public body overseen by the Finance Minister), sat on the board of Invest Ontario, and chaired the Ontario Place Redevelopment Corporation — all while his development company pursued a major financial claim against a provincial agency. The Globe and Mail reported he used his LCBO chairmanship to invite donors to a $1,000-a-head cash-for-access fundraiser for Finance Minister Vic Fedeli, drawing conflict-of-interest concerns from NDP MPP Marit Stiles.
Metrolinx's own 2024–25 annual report disclosed $8.2 billion in total outstanding legal claims against the agency — a figure that includes contractor disputes and other expropriations. The OLT has already ordered Metrolinx to pay $24 million and $88 million in two separate Ontario Line expropriation cases. The Craft Kingsmen settlement, whatever its value, adds to a growing body of evidence that the Ford government's aggressive transit land acquisition strategy is creating enormous financial exposure — and that insiders are in a position to capitalize on it.
Legal actions
Ontario Land Tribunal — Craft Kingsmen $492.9M Expropriation Compensation Claim (opens in a new tab)
Confidential SettlementIn 2024, Craft Kingsmen Rail (East) Corp. filed a claim with the Ontario Land Tribunal seeking approximately $492.9 million in compensation from Metrolinx for the 2021–2022 expropriation of 35.5 acres of air rights above Union Station rail corridors. Craft Kingsmen argued they could have built highrise mixed-use towers over the expropriated corridor and that the development potential justified the nine-figure claim. Metrolinx countered that the characteristics of the expropriated properties made development "extremely difficult, if not impossible." In late 2025, the parties reached a confidential settlement. Metrolinx stated it "cannot provide further details on confidential settlements." The Ford government refused to disclose the settlement amount. The OLT case was closed.
Government activity on this file
via PoliMon · updated hourly- committees · Metrolinx, class actionnewStanding Committee on Government Agencies 2026-10-29Nov 6, 2026
…ee that’s responsible for agencies, that’s responsible for WSIB and things like Metrolinx, to ask some questions. I’m only asking for one hour—one hour—of Mr. Lang’s tim…
- committees · Ontario Place, Ontario Science Centre, Ring of Fire, Ontario Line, Metrolinx, development charges, Auditor General, affordable housing, First NationnewStanding Committee on Heritage, Infrastructure and Cultural Policy 2026-10-28Nov 3, 2026
…in Toronto; —contract execution for the new Ontario Science Centre facility at Ontario Place; —contract execution for the Stevenson Memorial Hospital redevelopment project…
Rippling effects
The settlement closes the OLT case but opens deeper questions about transparency at Metrolinx. The agency's blanket use of confidentiality to shield settlement amounts from public scrutiny means taxpayers cannot assess whether the payout was reasonable, inflated, or disproportionate to what Craft Kingsmen actually owned. Opposition parties have called for disclosure; the government has declined.
The case also illustrates the legal and financial risk embedded in the Ford government's GO Expansion program. Metrolinx expropriated dozens of properties — including air rights, land parcels, and development entitlements — as it moved to build out electrified GO service. Where those properties were held by well-connected developers with resources to mount protracted OLT proceedings, the cost of that expansion rises dramatically and non-transparently. The $8.2 billion in outstanding claims against Metrolinx as of March 2025 is a liability borne entirely by Ontario taxpayers.
Carmine Nigro's simultaneous roles as PC fundraiser, multi-board appointee, and claimant against a provincial agency represent the kind of structural conflict that the provincial Members' Integrity Act and public appointments guidelines are intended to prevent — but which Nigro occupied without formal recusal requirements, because the rules as written did not require it. The case adds to the pattern documented in the MZO scandal, the waterfront power grab, and the Greenbelt scandal: Ford's inner circle of developers is consistently positioned to benefit from provincial decisions, whether through fast-tracked zoning, board appointments, or confidential settlements with public agencies.
Sources
- Ford friend's company settles $500M air rights expropriation dispute with Metrolinx — Cambridge Today (The Trillium)
- Ford friend's company seeking $500M from Metrolinx in expropriation dispute — Barrie Today (The Trillium)
- Fengate, CRAFT and Kingsmen announce co-development partnership for the ORCA Project — PR Newswire
- Crombie calls for LCBO chair to resign over close ties to Doug Ford — Ontario Liberal Party
- LCBO chairman Carmine Nigro inviting donors to cash-for-access event for Finance Minister Fedeli — Globe and Mail
- $500M expropriation claim involving a friend of the premier is 'unique,' expropriation lawyers say — The Trillium
- Premier Ford won't say how much Metrolinx is paying his friend's company in air rights settlement — The Trillium






