Beer Store Privatization
$225M+Cost to Ontario
9 sources ↓TL;DR
Ford broke a legally binding provincial contract to give grocery giants and convenience store chains the right to sell alcohol — handing corporations billions in new revenue while costing Ontario taxpayers $225 million upfront and a projected $1.4 billion in lost tax revenue by 2030.
What was promised
Ford promised beer and wine in corner stores
“As we approach the Victoria Day weekend, it is time to acknowledge that Ontario is mature enough for this change and ready to join other jurisdictions in making life a little more convenient.”
Doug Ford, · 2018 campaign statement
What happened · Sep 5, 2024
Licensed convenience stores began selling beer, wine, cider and ready-to-drink cocktails on September 5, 2024, more than six years after the pledge.
Ford's government released its alcohol-market plan in December 2023 with a 2026 start, then accelerated it in May 2024. On September 5, 2024, about 4,180 licensed convenience stores began selling beer, wine, cider and ready-to-drink cocktails, with grocery and big-box stores following after October 31, 2024. Ending the Beer Store's master framework agreement early required the province to pay The Beer Store up to $225 million.
Who benefited
- The Beer Store (Brewers Retail Inc.) · $225M
Paid up to $225 million by the province under the 2024 early-implementation agreement to end its retail exclusivity early and keep at least 300 stores open through 2025; Global News reported in November 2025 that the full amount had been paid out.
Source: Booze is coming to Ontario corner stores. Here's what shoppers can expect — CBC Toronto (Sep 5, 2024), Ontario pays out full $225M to Beer Store as end of store closure commitment nears — Global News (Nov 21, 2025), Ontario keeps paying Beer Store agreement as alcohol revenue falls — Global News (May 15, 2025)
- Circle K
Couche-Tard's CEO told analysts that selling beer, cider, wine and ready-to-drink products in its roughly 600 eligible Ontario Circle K stores after the 2024 legislation change drove notable growth, with wine sales doubling year over year in central Canada. Sourced to two trade reports quoting the company's earnings statements.
Source: Strong beverage alcohol sales in Ontario behind Couche-Tard's strong third quarter results — CCentral (Mar 19, 2025), Couche-Tard leans on alcohol, food deals as profits dip — Strategy (Sep 3, 2025)
Promise: CBC News
Outcome: CBC News, Retail Insider
Who benefited
- Loblaw Companies Limited (Loblaws)
Loblaws is one of the large grocery chains (alongside Metro, Sobeys, Walmart and Costco) licensed to sell beer, wine and ready-to-drink alcoholic beverages under the Ford government's accelerated alcohol retail expansion, and is a board member of the Retail Council of Canada, which advocated for the changes.
- Metro Inc. · $225M (Beer Store early-implementation payment)
Metro is a grocery chain that gained the ability to sell beer, wine, cider and ready-to-drink cocktails under Ford's accelerated 2024 alcohol retail expansion (which cost taxpayers up to $225M in an early-implementation payment to The Beer Store). CBC News reported Metro sits on the board of directors of the Retail Council of Canada, the industry lobby group (alongside Loblaw, Sobeys, Walmart and Costco) that pushed for the expansion.
- Sobeys (Empire)
Sobeys parent Empire Co. Ltd. has been applying for more liquor licences to expand alcohol sales under Ford's accelerated Beer Store/retail expansion deal, per an emailed statement from an Empire spokesperson to the Globe and Mail; Empire also registered a lobbyist (Cody Mallette of Atlas Strategic Advisors) engaging the Ontario government on related matters.
- Walmart Canada Corp.
As part of the Ford government's 2024 acceleration of alcohol retail liberalization (ending The Beer Store's exclusive monopoly on large-format beer sales), Walmart big-box locations in Ontario became licensed to sell beer, wine, cider, and ready-to-drink beverages alongside Costco and grocery chains, directly benefiting from the policy shift away from the Beer Store's regulated monopoly.
- Costco
As the final stage of the Ford government's alcohol retail expansion (which ended the Beer Store's exclusivity via non-renewal of the Master Framework Agreement), all 41 Ontario Costco locations received AGCO liquor licences and began selling beer, wine, cider and ready-to-drink cocktails on October 31, 2024.
- Circle K
Circle K is a confirmed member of the Convenience Industry Council of Canada (CICC), the trade group that advocated for Ontario's alcohol retail deregulation. Circle K directly benefited from the policy change, rolling out beer, cider, wine and ready-to-drink alcohol sales at roughly 600 of its Ontario locations starting September 5, 2024, when the province ended the Beer Store's near-monopoly on off-site alcohol retail.
- The Beer Store (Brewers Retail Inc.) · $225M
The Beer Store (Brewers Retail Inc.) and its owners received a $225M early-implementation payment to end its exclusive framework agreement early (CBC). FAO also counts $489M in industry supports to Brewers Retail and the wine industry.
Source: Why Doug Ford's booze sales plan could cost Ontario taxpayers far more than $225M - CBC (May 2024), The Financial Impact of Expanding the Beverage Alcohol Marketplace in Ontario - FAO (Jan 2025)
Key: People Related scandals
Why it matters
The Beer Store contract was not a vague policy commitment Ford could quietly abandon. It was a legally binding 10-year agreement, signed by the previous Liberal government in 2015, that gave The Beer Store (jointly owned by Molson, Labatt, and Sleeman) exclusive rights to sell 12- and 24-packs of beer until 2025. Ford broke it in 2024 and wrote a cheque for $225 million of public money — the equivalent of $382,653 per day — to exit the agreement 18 months early. No voter asked for this. No emergency required it. It was a political choice to accelerate a policy benefiting specific corporate interests on an arbitrary timeline, at a cost of a quarter-billion dollars.
The framing was always about consumer convenience — beer in corner stores, wine with your groceries. But the financial reality, documented by the province's independent Financial Accountability Office in January 2025, is a $1.4 billion net cost to Ontario taxpayers by 2030. The largest component — $1.28 billion — is lost tax revenue. Alcohol sold through the LCBO and Beer Store was subject to significant provincial markups and taxes that funded public services. Alcohol sold through Loblaws, Circle K, and Costco is not. Every bottle of wine sold at a grocery store instead of an LCBO is a bottle of foregone public revenue.
The beneficiaries of this arrangement are not hard to identify. The Retail Council of Canada — whose members include Loblaws, Metro, Sobeys, Walmart, and Costco — had lobbied intensively for expanded alcohol retail access. The Convenience Industry Council of Canada, representing Circle K and oil company-owned convenience chains, had done the same. These corporations now capture the profit margin on alcohol sales that previously supported Ontario's public finances. The Ford government accelerated their windfall by 18 months and billed taxpayers $225 million for the privilege.
The LCBO itself, in confidential corporate projections, forecast losing $600 million to $915 million in annual retail sales as a direct result of the privatization. As a Crown corporation whose profits flow to the provincial treasury, every dollar lost at the LCBO is a dollar not available for hospitals, schools, or transit.
Legal actions
The Financial Accountability Office of Ontario — the province's independent budget watchdog — released a comprehensive analysis in January 2025 finding that Ford's decision to expand and accelerate alcohol sales privatization would cost Ontario a net $1.4 billion by December 2030. The breakdown: $1.28 billion in lower tax revenues from the shift of alcohol sales to non-taxed private retailers, and $489 million in compensation to the wine industry and large breweries. The FAO found that $612 million of the total cost was specifically attributable to Ford's decision to accelerate the timeline — meaning the province paid extra to do this faster, generating no additional benefit.
In May 2024, the Ford government paid $225 million — $382,653 per day — to Molson and Labatt to exit Ontario's legally binding 10-year Beer Store agreement 18 months ahead of schedule. The contract had been signed in 2015 and represented a formal legal commitment by the province. No competitive process was run for the new arrangement; the province unilaterally broke the existing contract, absorbed the full financial penalty, and proceeded with the expansion. The payment was made without legislative approval or public consultation.
Rippling effects
The immediate human cost fell on LCBO workers. In July 2024, more than 9,000 LCBO employees walked off the job in the first strike in the Crown corporation's 98-year history. They were fighting for job security in the face of a privatization plan that everyone understood would eventually mean fewer LCBO stores and fewer LCBO jobs. The two-week strike ended with a contract, but the underlying threat — the systematic hollowing out of a public retail network — remained intact.
Beer Store locations began closing across Ontario as the business case for standalone alcohol retail collapsed. Communities that had relied on Beer Store locations — particularly in smaller towns where they were the only nearby option — lost them with no public consultation.
The FAO's $1.4 billion figure only covers impacts to December 2030. The long-term structural shift — permanently redirecting alcohol tax revenue from the public treasury to private retailers — will compound for decades. Ontario is not just losing $1.4 billion; it is permanently restructuring who profits from alcohol sales in the province, in favour of some of the country's wealthiest corporations.
Ford celebrated the policy as a victory for "the people" who wanted to buy beer at a corner store. The people who actually benefited were the shareholders of Loblaws, Sobeys, and Costco — who received a regulated market handed to them by government decree, at public expense, without competitive tender.
Linked bills
Sources
- The Financial Impact of Expanding the Beverage Alcohol Marketplace in Ontario — Financial Accountability Office of Ontario
- Why Doug Ford's booze sales plan could cost Ontario taxpayers far more than $225M — CBC News
- Ontario blowing $225-million to cancel its Beer Store contract is a scandal, not something to celebrate — The Globe and Mail
- Ford's government pays $225M to Molson and Labatt to allow lobbyists' clients to sell beer ahead of schedule — Open Council
- Thousands of LCBO workers on strike for 1st time after midnight deadline passes — CBC News
- Doug Ford's Alcohol Privatization Plan Will Cost Ontario Taxpayers Hundreds of Millions of Dollars — Press Progress
- Privatizing the sale of some alcoholic beverages will cost Ontarians $1.4 billion — NUPGE
- London Beer Store latest to close as union calls on Ontario voters to make alcohol sales an issue — CBC News
- Ontario budget watchdog to probe cost of Doug Ford's alcohol expansion plan — Global News

