Ford Gave Police Power to Stop Anyone and Closed Playgrounds, Then Reversed Within a Day, While Refusing Paid Sick Days
TL;DR
On April 16, 2021, at the height of the third wave, Ford's cabinet let police stop any pedestrian or driver to ask why they were out and closed playgrounds; police forces said they would not use the powers, and both measures were reversed the next day. Ford apologized on April 22 ("we got it wrong") and said for the first time that Ontario was working on paid sick days, which his own science table had urged and his government had resisted.
Key: People Related scandals
The web
3 peopleWhy it matters
The police powers let officers stop any pedestrian or driver during the stay-at-home order to ask why they had left home and to request their home address. The Canadian Civil Liberties Association's executive director, Michael Bryant, called it "the unconstitutional Friday standard." Police forces said before the reversal that they would not use it. "The HRPS will NOT be randomly stopping vehicles for no reason during the pandemic or afterwards," Halton Police Chief Steve Tanner tweeted, according to The Canadian Press via CTV.
The playground closure ran against the evidence on outdoor spread. "Science is clear: Outdoor COVID transmission is extremely rare," said Dr. Isaac Bogoch, a member of the province's own vaccine distribution task force. Infectious diseases specialist Dr. Sumon Chakrabarti said driving people indoors would make the problem worse (CTV News).
According to multiple unnamed sources cited by CBC News, the measures were made in a rush and "did not come from the government's health or scientific advisers." Cabinet had agreed on Thursday to a plan with next to no new restrictions, the sources said; on Friday Ford was advised that was not enough to satisfy the public, and after a new cabinet meeting the announcement slid from 2:30 p.m. to after 4 p.m. Two sources told CBC that Attorney General Doug Downey raised concerns in cabinet that the police powers were unconstitutional and was overruled. Insiders disagreed about who proposed them: some blamed chief of staff James Wallace and principal secretary Amin Massoudi, others Health Minister Christine Elliott (playgrounds) and Solicitor General Sylvia Jones (police powers), and others PC campaign director Kory Teneycke and pollster Nick Kouvalis. A senior government official told CBC: "We will admit it was rushed."
What the government did not do was what its advisers had asked for. CBC reports the cabinet did not act on recommendations from the province's COVID-19 Science Advisory Table, such as mandating paid sick days and paring back the list of essential workplaces. Ford had long rebuffed calls for paid sick days, pointing to the federal recovery sickness benefit and warning against "double dipping," CTV reported.
Rippling effects
The reversal came within about 24 hours. On Saturday, April 17, Jones said police would only be able to stop people they have reason to believe are participating in an "organized public event or social gathering," and Ford tweeted that "our regulations will be amended to allow playgrounds." Other outdoor closures, such as golf courses, stayed in place. That same day the number of COVID-19 patients in Ontario hospitals rose above 2,000 for the first time, with 726 in intensive care.
On April 22, isolating at home after a staff member tested positive, Ford apologized: "We got it wrong, we made a mistake… I'm sorry and I sincerely apologize," and said some of the measures, "especially around enforcement, they went too far." He said the province was now working on its own paid sick leave program, which CityNews described as something his government had resisted since the pandemic began. Later that day his press secretary said the government "will not impose any additional burden on the backs of Ontario businesses," and Ford gave no details or timeline.
Critics said the apology changed little. NDP Leader Andrea Horwath said Ford "chose to walk people into a catastrophic third wave" and called for paid sick days, closure of non-essential businesses, and vaccines for hot spots. Liberal Leader Steven Del Duca said Ford's "cold-hearted refusal to introduce paid sick days for more than a year has already cost lives." CUPE Ontario president Fred Hahn said it was "time for far more than assurance that he'll work on something."
For the government's earlier pandemic record in the province's care homes, see Long-Term Care COVID Deaths.
Sources
- Ontario walks back new pandemic police powers following widespread backlash — CTV News (The Canadian Press)
- Premier Ford reverses decision to close Ontario playgrounds amid backlash — CTV News
- The inside story of Doug Ford's COVID-19 climbdowns — CBC News
- 'We got it wrong': Ford apologizes for controversial COVID-19 measures — CityNews Toronto
- 'We got it wrong': Doug Ford apologizes for some of Ontario's enhanced public health measures — CTV News


