Metrolinx Investigates Its Own GO Train Safety Violations, and Publishes Nothing
TL;DR
Leaked Metrolinx records reported by The Trillium show GO and UP Express trains ran stop signals at least 22 times, broke speed limits at least 12 times and entered protected work zones at least 13 times since 2015, and Metrolinx investigated nearly all of them itself without publishing the results. In January 2026 a GO train near Oakville went through a stop signal at about 112 km/h in a 24 km/h zone; the Transportation Safety Board told the Toronto Star it was not investigating.
Key: People Related scandals
The web
4 peopleWhy it matters
The federal Transportation Safety Board investigates rail incidents independently and publishes its reports. But according to The Trillium, its jurisdiction covers federally owned track that carries only about 10 per cent of Metrolinx's train operations. On the rest, Metrolinx investigates itself, and its reports are not made public. The Toronto Star reports the TSB investigates incidents on provincial railways only at the request of Ontario's Ministry of Transportation.
The Trillium reported that, according to leaked Metrolinx documents, GO and UP Express trains have driven through stop signals at least 22 times, broken speed limits at least 12 times and entered protected track work zones at least 13 times since 2015, nearly two-thirds of them since 2020. Just two of 73 serious infractions logged in an internal Metrolinx spreadsheet from 2017 to 2023 were noted as referred to the TSB. The incidents described include an April 2018 GO train that ran a stop signal directly into the path of a CN freight train, and an August 2024 train that entered a 24 km/h slow zone at almost 80 km/h. Minister Prabmeet Sarkaria said there are "set criteria" for when Metrolinx refers incidents to the TSB; neither he nor Metrolinx said what they are, and Sarkaria said he is not always told when the agency investigates itself.
The January 5, 2026 near-derailment near Oakville shows how this works in practice. The Star reports that the preliminary Metrolinx report listed "regulatory and reputational risk" among the agency's concerns, that an internal investigation was to be finished within 60 to 75 days, and that no report has been made public. The TSB said it was not investigating. Former TSB investigator Ian Naish told the Star it was "extremely surprising" the train did not derail, and told The Trillium: "Any railway company that's investigating itself, I'd say they can't do that. It just doesn't work … because they're not independent."
The TSB has warned about this before. In a 2023 report it said it "is concerned the Province of Ontario does not provide effective safety oversight of provincially regulated railways." TSB chair Yoan Marier told The Trillium his agency has received no updates from Ontario on improved rail oversight since then.
Government activity on this file
via PoliMon · updated hourly- committees · Metrolinx, class actionnewStanding Committee on Government Agencies 2026-10-29Nov 6, 2026
…ee that’s responsible for agencies, that’s responsible for WSIB and things like Metrolinx, to ask some questions. I’m only asking for one hour—one hour—of Mr. Lang’s tim…
- committees · Ontario Place, Ontario Science Centre, Ring of Fire, Ontario Line, Metrolinx, development charges, Auditor General, affordable housing, First NationnewStanding Committee on Heritage, Infrastructure and Cultural Policy 2026-10-28Nov 3, 2026
…in Toronto; —contract execution for the new Ontario Science Centre facility at Ontario Place; —contract execution for the Stevenson Memorial Hospital redevelopment project…
Rippling effects
Requests for independent investigation have gone unanswered. On March 16, 2026, Transport Action Ontario wrote to Metrolinx CEO Michael Lindsay and Minister Sarkaria asking Metrolinx to "immediately transfer responsibility for this investigation and all other near-miss incident investigations to the Transportation Safety Board of Canada." In a post published in April, the group said it had sent a follow-up two weeks later and had still received no response. It also raised concern that the two Alstom crew members were dismissed before any independent investigation was complete.
GO trains still have no automatic safety backstop. According to The Trillium, Metrolinx trains rely entirely on crews to obey trackside signals; there is no system that brakes automatically when a train passes a stop signal or exceeds a speed limit, as modern train control does in the United States, Australia and much of Europe and Asia. Metrolinx has said it plans to install the European train control system but has given no timeline. Marier warned: "Until these defences are implemented, the risk will remain, and you could have a similar occurrence tomorrow or next week."
The government's answer has been reassurance. A spokesperson for the transportation minister told the Star that "Metrolinx has one of the strongest safety records in North America" and that the government is "confident the existing processes provide the oversight required." Sarkaria told The Trillium: "Our record speaks for the level of safety that we not only expect, but hold our team to." Metrolinx said it works with Alstom, whose employees operate GO trains, to hold employees responsible after violations.
This is the operations side of a wider safety-transparency problem at the agency. Separate leaked reports show serious near-misses on Metrolinx construction sites, documented in Leaked Metrolinx Reports Reveal Dozens of Serious Construction Near-Misses.
Sources
- When GO trains break 'cardinal rules,' Ontario keeps investigations secret — The Trillium
- GO train near Oakville was seconds away from 'worst-case' derailment, internal Metrolinx report shows — Toronto Star
- Metrolinx overspeed incident demonstrates urgent need for Enhanced Train Control, requires independent investigation — Transport Action Ontario


