Skip to content
Independent · Sourced
← All individuals
Paul Calandra

Paul Calandra

MPP for Markham—Stouffville: voting record

InstigatorBeneficiary

Estimated cost to Ontario

$8.3B

Ontario Minister of Education under Doug Ford. Ordered the placement of six school boards under provincial supervision in 2025, citing financial mismanagement. Issued the June 2025 regulation giving the province direct authority to direct school board property sales. Previously served as Municipal Affairs and Housing Minister.

Connected scandals

  • The Ford government passed legislation giving the Minister of Education power to force school boards to sell public land to private developers, then used manufactured financial crises to take over six school boards — handing control of an estimated $60 billion in public land to provincial-appointed supervisors with real estate backgrounds and no education experience.

    As Minister of Education, Calandra ordered the provincial takeover of six school boards in 2025 and approved the June 2025 regulation allowing the province to directly control school board property sales. He appointed real estate and finance insiders — rather than educators — as supervisors, and has put all boards "on notice" regardless of their financial standing.

  • The Ford government stripped elected trustees of all authority at 8 of Ontario's largest school boards — covering 750,000 students — installing politically-connected supervisors and passing legislation that removed the courts as a check on ministerial power.

    As Education Minister, Calandra personally directed all eight school board takeovers between April 2025 and March 2026, sponsored Bill 33 to expand and insulate ministerial takeover powers, and appointed all supervisors — including briefly serving as PDSB supervisor himself.

  • Ontario Education Minister Paul Calandra is preparing legislation to abolish elected trustees across English public school boards — eliminating a century of local democratic governance — after spending a year seizing 8 of Ontario's largest boards under "public interest" powers his own government wrote into law.

    As Minister of Education, Calandra sponsored Bill 33 (Supporting Children and Students Act, 2025), which expanded ministerial takeover powers and stripped school boards of their right to judicial review. He has placed 8 boards under provincial supervision and has promised legislation to eliminate elected English public school board trustees, stating they have "no constitutional or Charter guarantees." He confirmed in March 2026 that "significant change" to trustee governance is coming and that no notwithstanding clause would be needed.

  • The Ford government has tabled Bill 101 — the Putting Student Achievement First Act — replacing elected directors of education with CEOs requiring business credentials, gutting trustees' budget and bargaining powers, and mandating government-approved lesson plans in every classroom, while education unions warn it is a roadmap to corporate control of Ontario's public schools.

    As Minister of Education, Calandra tabled Bill 101 (Putting Student Achievement First Act, 2026) on April 13, 2026, abolishing the position of Director of Education and replacing it with a CEO requiring business credentials, capping trustees at 12 per board, removing trustees from collective bargaining, mandating government-approved classroom resources, and granting the minister new powers to restrict board political speech and override capital projects.

  • CityNews Queen's Park reporter Tina Yazdani was fired without explanation in April 2026 — days after a confrontational on-camera exchange with Education Minister Paul Calandra, and after at least two of her Ford government stories were quietly deleted from the Rogers-owned network's website in apparent violation of Rogers' own editorial standards.

    As Ontario Minister of Education, Calandra had a confrontational on-camera exchange with Yazdani on March 25, 2026, telling her "Don't interrupt me" during her coverage of his memo to school boards. The story was removed from the CityNews website without explanation shortly after airing. Yazdani was terminated weeks later.

  • A leaked Ministry of Education ad script obtained by The Trillium shows actors playing parents criticizing teacher unions over sick days and doctor's notes, produced while five major education unions have suspended bargaining. Education Minister Paul Calandra defended the campaign; ETFO's president called it a taxpayer-funded smear campaign.

    Education Minister who defended the planned ads, citing a responsibility to address "inconsistent attendance" and saying "we will not shy away from communicating directly with parents." The leaked script is labelled "Ministry of Education: Student Achievement First" and dated July 10, 2026. NDP critic Chandra Pasma separately blamed Calandra for "ragging the puck in bargaining."

  • $8.3B+

    Premier Doug Ford secretly handed 15 parcels of protected Greenbelt farmland to well-connected developers through a three-week backroom process — a windfall worth $8.3 billion to those developers — and only reversed it after the Auditor General publicly exposed the scheme.

    As Minister of Municipal Affairs and Housing, Calandra pledged in October 2023 that "the province will work with impacted municipalities to assist with related planning and staffing costs." A briefing note obtained by CBC through FOI — prepared for senior civil servants and for Calandra — records that just over five months later he gave civil servants a direction, on the basis of which "the ministry has not done any proactive outreach to municipalities to solicit cost submissions." The specifics of that direction are not disclosed in the released records. The note states "no decision has been made on reimbursement to these municipal costs."

  • Ontario now routes elementary teachers' $750 classroom supply allowance through a single Staples portal, which The Trillium reports is a $66 million program. Since it launched on Sept. 1, teachers have reported prices above what their boards paid before, orders stuck without shipping details, and some teachers have been told they cannot get full access until Oct. 9.

    As Education Minister, his office announced the $750 Staples spending cards for teachers on August 13, 2026, and he acknowledged the Staples portal would have mistakes when it launched on September 1.

Bills

Promises (4)

Partly kept

Calandra said Ontario would amend or revoke zoning orders that did not deliver results

“I have always been clear that if we do not see the results we expect from a zoning order, our government will not hesitate to amend or revoke it.”

· Ontario government news release

What happened · Mar 31, 2026

Six of the eight orders proposed for revocation or amendment were revoked in April 2024 and one was amended, but no decision has been posted on the 14 housing orders put under 18 months of 'enhanced monitoring', and the government reposted that proposal in March 2026 as still open.

On December 13, 2023, the province proposed revoking or amending eight non-housing zoning orders and put 14 housing orders under 'enhanced monitoring' for 18 months. On April 9, 2024, Calandra made O. Reg. 165/24, which revoked six of them (Oro-Medonte, Brampton, Kingston, Markham 482/22 and two in McNab/Braeside). He amended the Pickering order and decided not to revoke Markham O. Reg. 599/21. In December 2024 the Auditor General found that 'The Ministry has not defined what constitutes sufficient progress, or the timeline that such progress needs to be achieved.' The enhanced-monitoring notice was 'reposted on March 31, 2026 to tell the public that the proposal remains open,' and no decision has been posted on those 14 orders.

Broken

Calandra said the province would help cover municipalities' costs from his official-plan reversals; Guelph and Wellington County say they were never paid

“In recognition of the costs incurred by municipalities arising out of this decision, the province will work with impacted municipalities to assist with related planning and staffing costs.”

· Minister's statement, Ontario Newsroom

What happened · Aug 24, 2026

A September 2024 ministry briefing note said no decision had been made on reimbursement and the ministry had not asked municipalities for their costs; Guelph and Wellington County, both covered by the statement, told CBC in August 2026 they had not been reimbursed.

Calandra's October 23, 2023 statement reversed provincial changes to the official plans of 12 municipalities, including Guelph and Wellington County, and pledged help with the resulting planning and staffing costs. A briefing note obtained by CBC News through freedom of information says that, on Calandra's direction about five months later, 'the ministry has not done any proactive outreach to municipalities to solicit cost submissions' and that 'no decision has been made on reimbursement.' In August 2026 Guelph and Wellington County confirmed to CBC they had not been reimbursed; Guelph put its cost at nearly $64,000. Pickering, Durham Region and Grimsby, whose separate claims relate to the Greenbelt removals, also say they have not been paid. The province did not respond to CBC's request for comment.

Who was hurt

Kept

Calandra said developers would get no compensation for the Greenbelt reversal

“At this point nothing had changed. The lands had been temporarily moved out of the Greenbelt, but no zoning had been changed, the circumstances for them had not changed, so that's why I'm not going to be offering any compensation.”

· Remarks to reporters (The Canadian Press)

What happened · Aug 28, 2026

The 2023 act that restored the lands added immunity provisions that wiped out related claims, the Court of Appeal upheld them on August 28, 2026, and no compensation payment has been reported.

The Greenbelt Statute Law Amendment Act, 2023 (Royal Assent December 6, 2023) 'strengthens immunity provisions', according to the ministry's decision notice. It also ended the province's 2022 settlement with Minotar Holdings. The Superior Court dismissed Minotar's constitutional challenge in March 2025. On August 28, 2026, the Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal 2-1. Minotar filed a separate claim in November 2025 seeking $300 million for breach of contract, and that claim has not been decided.

Broken

Calandra tabled a motion to approve Steve Clark's reprimand, then never called it for a vote

“That the Legislative Assembly accept the report of the Integrity Commissioner dated August 30, 2023 and approve the recommendation contained therein.”

· Government notice of motion (Motion 17), Orders and Notices

What happened · Oct 26, 2023

The government never called its own motion for debate or a vote, and the government House leader told the House on October 26, 2023 he had "no intention of moving forward beyond that."

On August 30, 2023, Integrity Commissioner J. David Wake found that Steve Clark contravened sections 2 and 3(2) of the Members' Integrity Act, 1994 and recommended that the Assembly reprimand him. On September 25, 2023, Government House Leader Paul Calandra filed a motion to approve that recommendation and the same day sought unanimous consent to put it to a vote without debate or amendment, which was refused. On October 26, 2023, asked when the motion would be debated, Calandra said that because Clark had accepted responsibility and resigned, he had "no intention of moving forward beyond that." The motion was still listed on the Orders and Notices Paper, never debated or voted on, as of December 5, 2024.

Sources

↑↓ move↵ focus⌘↵ open page→ start a path from here