
Bonnie Lysyk
Office of the Auditor General of Ontario
Former Ontario Auditor General (2013–2023). In November 2021, Lysyk released a landmark value-for-money audit on species at risk protection finding: permits to harm endangered species had increased 6,262% since 2009 (from 13 to over 800 annually); the Ministry of Environment had never denied a single permit application to harm at-risk species; ministry staff had "no direction on when to reject permit applications that would do harm, and consequently, they are always approved"; 10 of 15 members on the species advisory committee worked for industry, half as registered lobbyists; and no inspections were conducted to ensure permit conditions were followed. The Ford government's response was Bill 5, which made the audit's findings permanent by repealing the Endangered Species Act entirely.
Connected scandals
The Ford government promised a comprehensive environmental assessment for a proposed landfill directly upstream from Canada's only population of the salamander mussel — then buried the reversal inside omnibus Bill 5 after winning a byelection on the promise, exempting a company whose owners donated $200,000 to the PCs from all provincial environmental review, leaving 33 species at risk in one of Canada's most biodiverse rivers with no provincial protection.
Her 2021 Auditor General report documented that permits to harm endangered species had increased 6,262% under Ford and the province had never denied a single application — findings that the Ford government's Bill 5 then made permanent by repealing the Endangered Species Act.
Auditor General Bonnie Lysyk found Ontario's early pandemic response was slower than other provinces', run through a cumbersome command structure that was not led by public health experts, and hobbled by SARS-era lessons that were never acted on. Doug Ford called the report "21 pages of inaccuracies" and told her to "stick with looking for value for money."
As Auditor General, tabled the November 25, 2020 special report finding Ontario's COVID-19 response "slower and more reactive" than other provinces', run by a command structure "not led by public health expertise," with SARS-era lessons unimplemented. Stood by the report after the premier attacked it, saying it was vetted for factual accuracy and its recommendations were accepted.
The Auditor General found Ontario paid more than $210 million in Small Business Support Grants to about 14,500 ineligible recipients and chose not to try to recover any of it, while nearly half of recipients got about $714 million more than they lost and some hard-hit businesses got nothing. Premier Doug Ford's answer: "I think more people benefited than got hurt."
As Auditor General, found in her 2021 Annual Report that more than $210 million in Small Business Support Grants went to ineligible recipients and that the province chose not to recover it. "Given the amount of money, the absence of better controls or assessment processes is troubling." On the missed conflict of interest: "It's not acceptable."